Well, I finally finished reading Breaking Dawn last night and I’m thinking it over. I have to admit that I’d heard so much about people loving/hating this book that I did a little digging beforehand. I didn’t want to read something I’d hate and that could potentially ruin the rest of the series for me.
However, regardless, I’m one of those people who just NEEDS closure. For instance, the end of Gone with the Wind killed me. I’ve had to watch the movie Scarlett numerous times to feel good about the way things were resolved. I like sequels and series and things like that, because I like finding out what happens next. A great ending to a series just seals the deal. I remember being so worried about reading The Deathly Hallows. Obviously, I had to, since I was beyond obsessed with finding out how it all went down. And to me, J.K. Rowling just wrapped everything up so great. It was such a satsifying ending. And after hearing some different reviews about Breaking Dawn, I was worried. (Despite the fact that I had a small idea of what was to come.)
So here are my thoughts. I very much enjoyed the beginning. (Spoiler Warning!! Do not read further if you haven’t finished the book!) The wedding and all that was so great–something we were all waiting for. My issues began when she suddenly began speaking from Jacob’s point of view. She’s stayed with Bella’s voice through the whole series, and then decides to give us Jacob’s perspective. I know he’s an important character, but really, I’d rather hear Edward’s voice–and still, I’d really rather she just stay consistent with Bella’s voice. I did think she strayed a bit from the original characters. In the sense that some of their choices and actions just seemed so inconsistent with their behavior throughout. Like Renee being totally fine with the wedding. Like Charlie taking about five minutes to adjust to the idea of wolves, and vampires, and Reneesme, and Bella becoming a vampire, etc. We’ve loved Bella’s clumsiness and vulnerability and deep-felt concern for others. She becomes superwoman–really supervampire-woman. In some ways, she didn’t seem like Bella anymore to me.
Apart from that, once we left Jacob and moved back into Bella’s perspective, I did enjoy much of the rest of the book. But it did seem as though we’d read hundreds of pages of build-up for basically everyone to walk away unscathed. And I’m hoping that was her original plan–and she didn’t write it that way because it was easier than making a battle scene and killing characters.
The whole idea of imprinting is creepy in so many ways. I didn’t like that aspect of the book at all. It’s just beyond weird for these guys/wolves to fall in love with toddlers and wait around for them to grow up so that then the girl can automatically fall back in love with them and live happily ever after. So Jacob imprinting on Reneesme was over-the-top for me. And Edward calling Jacob “son” at the end of the book! Unbelievable.
Here’s the thing–since Bella is such a super-strong vampire-woman, why didn’t she do anything when she felt rage about Jacob imprinting on her daughter? She just gets over it without a problem. Some of that just seemed out-of-character for her. Since she was now so powerful, I was hoping we’d at least see her display that strength when it came to protecting her daughter–even if she changed her mind or came around later. Just deciding to let Jacob make the shots by imprinting, bringing Charlie around, and basically moving in as the Cullen’s house-dog, was just really, really frustrating to me. Since when do they let Jacob run their family? I thought we’d see more protective/father from Edward too.
OK, once I’d moved past the frustration of Jacob’s role in practically every scene of the book, I have to say that I was so glad for the strength of the Bella/Edward relationship at the end. Their love and devotion to each other, and the idea that they really will love each other forever, was just so sweet. And the fact that they had a child was cool to me too–since we knew Bella couldn’t once she became a vampire.
Because of that aspect of the ending, I was glad I read the book. Really, it was all about Bella and Edward from the beginning. So finding their relationship come full circle was satisfying to me. And for some reason, I was glad that she threw in that other vampire/human character who was interested in Reneesme. Maybe because it indicates that Reneesme will have choices and experiences that aren’t all pre-determined for her by Jacob’s decision to imprint on her.
So when I closed the book, I was happy. I just went through a lot of frustration along the way. The happily ever after for everyone was less than I had hoped for–not that I’m not a happily-ever-after person. It’s just that there usually has to be some pain and sacrifice to reach that point. I think it was easier and safer to keep everyone happy and in love and together.
But as long as Bella and Edward are happy and in love, I can roll with it.
My overall thoughts on the series–I really appreciate Stephanie Meyer’s creativity. She came up with a great story. (I think she said it was actually a dream she had.) And I’d read it all over again to meet Bella and Edward. There were some super-interesting sidebars to the story–like Edward’s fear that they’ve lost their souls and Carlisle’s belief that there would be an afterlife for them. I would’ve enjoyed seeing this developed a bit. The histories of how the characters all became vampires were so interesting, especially Carlisle’s story. The decision for Bella and Edward to get married before she turned into a vampire was great. Characters like Alice and Jasper and Rosalie made the story so much more enjoyable.
I can’t wait for the next movie!